Batiste, seated at a colorful piano, brought a distinct New Orleans jazz flavor to the anthem — a bold and soulful twist on a familiar song. His passionate performance left some of the NFL players in the stands visibly emotional.

But for fans, especially those on X (formerly Twitter), it sparked heated debate: Was it a masterpiece, or did it stray too far from tradition?

Looking back at Super Bowl performances, a few renditions are often hailed as the gold standard. Whitney Houston’s 1991 performance still holds a special place in many hearts. Lady Gaga’s powerful 2016 rendition also stands out, as does Chris Stapleton’s tear-jerking performance last year.

Even Travis Kelce, the three-time Super Bowl champ, recently said that  Stapleton’s rendition remains unmatched in his eyes.

But with Batiste’s take on the anthem, it feels like a new era. While some fans celebrated his unique twist on the anthem, others preferred the traditional, straightforward approach. And for every fan who felt moved, there were others who questioned if jazz was the right way to go for such a high-stakes moment.

The Brooches Jon Batiste wore

Batiste also made a bold fashion statement with not one, but two Tiffany Bird on a Rock brooches. These stunning pieces, a symbol of luxury and elegance, are among the most recognizable in the jewelry world, thanks to their iconic design by Jean Schlumberger for Tiffany & Co. in 1965.

The brooches themselves are a masterpiece — featuring a bird set with a white diamond and perched on a cabochon rock, the perfect blend of sophistication and sparkle.

While the original design was created for Bunny Mellon, a close friend of Schlumberger, the pieces have since been worn by A-listers like Lady Gaga, Odell Beckham, and Jeremy Allen White, cementing their status as a timeless jewelry icon.

Batiste’s choice of brooches didn’t just add to his stylish ensemble; it made a statement. The combination of the citrine and diamond elements made for a striking contrast that perfectly matched his performance at the Super Bowl. And with Tiffany & Co.’s longstanding association with the NFL—designing the Vince Lombardi trophy since 1966 — it’s clear that Batiste’s jewelry choice was more than just a nod to luxury. It was a part of a legacy, according to Town and country magazine.

While we may never know for sure whether the jewelry had any connection to the game (could he have been subtly rooting for the Chiefs or Eagles?), it was undeniably a bold move that had everyone talking. A fashion moment to remember—and certainly one for the jewelry books.

So, what’s your take? Did Jon Batiste deliver a performance for the ages, or does it fall short of the unforgettable renditions we’ve come to expect at the Super Bowl? Watch him sing below and share your thoughts below and join the debate!